Below is the link to an article from CNN discussing the removal of U.S. troops from Iraq. After reading it, answer the following questions thoughtfully and thoroughly.
- Do you think it is possible for the U.S. to build a “’normal relationship’” with Iraq given everything that has happened between the two nations in the past eight years of war? Why or why not?
- What do Obama and al-Maliki hope will happen to Iraq once the U.S. military is no longer present there? Do you think their visions for Iraq are possible?
- Do you think it is a good thing that the United States is withdrawing its military presence from Iraq? Why or why not?
1) I do not think it is possible for the U.S. to build a completely normal relationship with Iraq given everything that has happened. Although the war has ended and both Obama and al-Maliki are working together, there will still be grudges between both countries. The U.S. lost 4,400 troops who lives cannot be replaced, or whose families cannot recover from losing their loved ones. The same can be said about the 100,000 Iraqi soldiers and innocent people killed. On the other hand in some ways the U.S. and Iraq will be able to make amends. The U.S. and Iraq will be able to trade with one another which would include the U.S. selling 18 more F-16 fighter jets to Iraq, which would help replace the ones broken in the war. Not to mention the U.S. helping train security personnel to make sure Iraq is safe. To sum it up, I think the U.S. and Iraq will partially be able to have a normal relationship with one another.
ReplyDelete2) Obama and al-Maliki hope that Iraq will be able to protect themselves from other countries by themselves after all the U.S. troops leave. I think this is completely possible if the Iraqi people are willing to train with the American troops and learn how to protect their country effectively. The article states, “The U.S. goal "is a sovereign Iraq that can protect its borders, protect its airspace, protect its people," Obama said.” This quote really describes that with a little help Iraq can be protected, by their own people. With the U.S. selling Iraq fighter jets, the Iraqi air force would be stronger, which would allow the country to be safer. And as mentioned before if the U.S. troops helped train security apparatus, Iraq would be a lot closer to their goal of good security. Overall, I believe it is possible for Iraq to reach its goal of having a self-reliant security once the U.S. leaves Iraq.
3) I think it is a good thing that the U.S. is withdrawing its military from Iraq. With the troops gone Iraq can really focus on their goal of having good security for their country. When the U.S. troops were there Iraq was too focused on fighting a war that they had no time to improve their security. Although the U.S. in some ways did help protect Iraqi people, if Iraq can learn to do this themselves they would be so much stronger.
1) I do not think it is possible. One beacause I dont think we could ever forgive them on what they did to us which is starting a war. Second I dont think we could trust them if we did forgive them.
ReplyDelete2) They hope that Iraq can protect themselves with out US help. Well I think they are possible but they would need to have their own military and not take ours.
3) I think it is a good thing beacuse the US does not need more people dead. We need to send our troops home and not send more in.
1. I agree with Baylee because I also think that it would be impossible for the United States and Iraq to form any sort of "normal relationship" given everything that's occurred between the two nations over the past eight years of war. There was too much fighting that went on and people hold grudges. Also, no one can go from being enemies of war to allies that quickly. There's much more to it than just an agreement. Too many lives were lost to forget everything that happened. The United States lost 4,400 lives in that eight-year war, and those are 4,400 people that the U.S. can't get back; that their families can't get back. The hurt of this war was too great to forget and move on.
ReplyDelete2. Obama and al-Maliki hope that once the U.S. military is no longer present in Iraq, that it will be able to protect its own borders, airspace and people. I do not believe that these wishes are possible because the people of Iraq do not have enough education on how to use the weapons and how to defend their nation. They cannot do it alone if we have had to be there, protecting their country for them for all these years. Also, I understand that they will be trained on how to use the weapons, but still, they don't have the war tactic needed to defend a nation on their own.
3. I do not think it is a good idea that we are withdrawing our forces from Iraq because it is unsafe. In doing this, we would be putting more Iraqi lives in danger because their military is not prepared to defend a whole nation on their own yet. Then again, I think that it's a good idea to withdraw our troops because they are our soldiers and we want them to be safe and at home again. Their families need them and we can't risk the lives of our men to protect another nation. Also, I agree with Baylee and think that if we withdraw our soldiers, we are giving Iraq the opportunity to prove themselves and be able to take care of their country. This will end up making them stronger and more self-reliant and independent.
1. Over time, yes. I believe that there is a possibility of Iraq and America becoming allies. Probably not right away but eventually. I agree with Lizzie and Baylee that the war killed so many people that it will be hard to do. I do not believe that it will ever be forgotten. As the generations move on, no one will have a hatred for Iraq because they killed their great great grandfather. i mean yes its sad but since that person didn't have a direct connection with the soldier that died, they wont feel as strongly about it. I mean, how many of you hate all Germans because their ancestors killed your ancestors? People forgive. We never forget though because then history would repeat itself. You can't go through life holding grudges though, or you'll never get anywhere.
ReplyDelete2. Obama and al-Maliki hope that when the American Troops leave Iraq, they will be able to protect their country. I think that they will be able to do it alone because hopefully, they will be growing as a nation. No one can start off with an amazing army. They have to learn, gain experience, and grow. If they have someone "puppy guarding" them forever they will never be able to do it on their own. Maybe they won't start off strong, but i believe they will get there.
3. I think it is a great idea to withdraw the troops from Iraq. I think that we are just putting our country in more danger by being there and causing more problems. I am the type of person to stay out of things unless i feel attacked. If america no longer has a reason to be there then get out. My sister is in the Army and so is her husband. He was in Iraq and she tells me how worried she was everyday that she would never see him again. If people don't have to go through that and be put in that position, then why would they? I think getting the troops out of iraq is the only way to end the war for good.
With some time and forgiveness, I think that a relatively “normal relationship” can be established between the two nations. There's nothing that replaces the thousands of lives lost and the permanent imprint the U.S. has made on the people there but neither nation will get anywhere on the issue if some sort of compromise isn't reached. I'm guessing that its not going to be easy and many people will be against the idea. Also forgiveness isn't so effortlessly reached by those who have had loved ones lost or homes destroyed. But I think, with time and understanding, the nations will be able to be at least on good terms. I'm pretty sure that the overall goal of invading Iraq was only to help but that a lot of people didn't/don't see it like that at all which makes things a little more complicated already.
ReplyDeleteObama and al-Maliki hope that once the U.S. military leaves Iraq that the nation will be able to support itself and prosper for the most part independently. I think that Iraq is fully capable of maintaining their own country. The U.S. has tried somewhat successfully to help Iraq set up their government and such and hopefully Iraq will be able build further off of what is existing currently. Ever country has to start somewhere; I mean even the U.S. had its moments but it has all lead up to where we are now. Iraq can be the same way and choose to improve its current state of being. In other words, the U.S. had provided them with the foundation and given them the opportunity, now its up to Iraq to decide where to go from there.
I think that withdrawing the U.S. military from Iraq will be beneficial for the nation. For eight years the U.S. has been trying to help Iraq and hopefully now by removing the military we will be able to give them a little breathing room for them to sort things out on their own. I don't doubt that military support might have been needed but I think Iraq needs a chance to prove itself, like Baylee said. If Iraq still needs help then it will be evident and whether we decide to help them in that instance is a question for the future. Also, like many others have stated as well, U.S. families and friends want their loved ones back from war.
I think over time they could possibly work out a way to build a normal relationship between The united states and Iraq. It all takes forgiveness and stability of both countries if they really want to work this out. People would be totally against it, many would but if they all work on having forgiveness in both countries than i think it could be possible but definitely not rushed because it will take time to heal all the wounds both countries caused for each other and the death people will need to deal with and never forget.
ReplyDeleteObama and AL-Maliki hope that once the us troops are out of Iraq they will be able to protect ans support them selves. I think its easily possible for them to do it because if it wasn't they wouldn't be their own nation. If they decide to learn from the us troops and grow as themselves to reach the point they want to be but they have to be dedicated to what they want to accomplish. If they do that than i think they can do it perfectly fine and they should be able to support and protect themselves as a growing nation.
I think it would be a good idea to withdraw the troops from Iraq. In this case now they can work on growing and accomplishing things without the u.s help. It will be accomplishing for them in the long run and removing the u.s will give Iraq a chance to prove themselves as Edj said. They can be independent and work on their own problems as a nation. I totally agree with Sami, if they don't need to be there why should they be? Removing them would just be a great huge step of ending this war that we all want to be over. Also like others have mentioned the u.s soldiers will be back with their loved ones and family which would bring great joy to their families and lives to be home where they belong.
1)Like Lizzie and Baylee said, I do not think that the United States and Iraq will completely overcome what happened in the war,but they will have a relatively normal relationship. Of course, it is possible for them to forgive each other and be on good terms, but they are not going to be able to completely forget what happened. However, the article says that Iraq might possibly become a democratic government, so I think that the United States and Iraq will be able to work things out and maybe become allies. Also, like Edj said, nothing is going to be able to replace all of the lives lost, and I feel that the citizens in each country will always hold a small grudge towards the other country. The countries are not going to be successful and move forward if they keep holding a grudge and they do not make a compromise with each other. Overall, I think that they will be able to establish a relatively normal relationship, because both countries need to come to a compromise in order to move forward.
ReplyDelete2)When the U.S troops leave Iraq, Obama and Al-Maliki both want Iraq to be able to move forward and be on its own. As Obama said in the article, "Our goal is to simply make sure Iraq succeeds,because we think a successful, democratic Iraq can be a model for the entire region." I think that this vision for Iraq is possible because since the United States was there for a long time to help them get started in the right direction, they will be able to build off of that and I think that they could have learned from what the United States had done. I also think that this is possible because they might not be successful in building their own democratic nation at first, but I think that with time they will be able to pull through and be successful.
3)I think that it is definetly a good idea for the United States to withdraw troops from Iraq for our own personal reasons, but on the other hand, like Lizzie said, it would be unsafe for Iraq. This is because the United States has been there for so long helping them protect themselves and building a foundation for them,and if the troops leave so suddenly, they will not have a good army to defend themselves, and I do not think that they will be able to come together that quickly. I also agree with Sami because if the United States no longer has to be in Iraq, then the smart idea would be to leave for good. Also, removing the troops from Iraq would save our soldiers like Sami's sister, and it would bring happiness to their loved ones. Nothing bad would happen to the United States if we removed the troops, but Iraq could be in great danger. Overall, I think that it would be a good idea for the United States to remove the troops from Iraq, but it could be very unsafe for Iraq.
1) I do believe that there can be a relatively normal relationship reached between the two nations, the U.S. and Iraq, because both president Obama and al-Maliki want to establish a normal relationship, and both of them know that in order for both countries to move foreword, they must compromise and become allies. I say relatively normal opposed to completely normal because politically the relationship will be normal, but by looking deeper into the two countries, there will still be some tension among the citizens. I agree with Edj that it is not effortless to forgive and forget all the loved ones, from both countries, that were lost in these past eight years, due to this war. There will always be some people who have hatred towards the other country, but the two countries will be considered "allies" in the eyes of politicians. For example, we will probably trade with Iraq and help them out when they are in need, but the relationship can never completely normal. We have left too many scars on each other for this goal to be attainable.
ReplyDelete2) Both Obama and al-Maliki want Iraq to be able to defend and protect itself in its entirety on its own. This includes defending Iraq's airspace, borders, and people. They also want to have Iraq be a democratic nation. I believe this is very possible. The article says, "[Obama] told the visiting Iraqi prime minister the two nations will build 'a comprehensive partnership' that includes trade relations, support for building up Iraq's democratic capacity and military-to-military ties aimed at helping Iraq rebuild its air force". This means that the United States will continue to help Iraq, but now in stead of helping by just protecting Iraq, the U.S. will help by teaching the Iraqi people how to protect themselves. I agree with Lizzie in that the Iraqi people are not yet militarily educated enough to go off on their own. I believe, however, that with the help that the U.S. plans to give the Iraqi people, they will do well on their own. As Sami and Edj said, Iraq may not start off strong, but everybody starts from somewhere. I believe that with a lot of effort the visions of Obama and al-Maliki will come true. The U.S. can not hold up Iraq forever. It is like a baby bird flying for the first time. It must be pushed away before it can soar.
3) Through and through I agree with Lizzie and Baylee By removing U.S. troops from Iraq, we are helping our people and our soldiers to be safe. We are also allowing Iraq to become more independent. On the negative side, Iraq is still unstable and unsafe, and when we leave, the Iraqi people may not be able to protect themselves, but I feel that if it means that both countries can move on to bettering themselves instead of just focusing on each other, it is worth it. In the long run, I feel that leaving is a good thing, as self reliance is the only way a country can grow, become safer, and become better in general. Like Edj said, by staying we are not allowing Iraq to prove itself. The U.S. has done all that it can in order to help Iraq, and it is not worth it if we have to stay there forever. The purpose of helping the country of Iraq is to get it on its feet and to be successful. Leaving is good because we can then see if our efforts were for good or for nothing.
1. I agree with Lizzie, Molly, and Baylee that they will be unable to have a “normal relationship.” I think this because when people go to war nit everyone is going to agree on who started it or the reason why it started. Therefore, there will still be grudges, in order to overcome those grudges we both have to forgive each other. But, unfortunately not everyone can forgive as easily as others. A normal relationship between with two nations is two countries that help out each other with support and can trust the other nation. The relationship between Iraq and us is anything but trustworthy because, after all we did go to war. Overall, I do not think it will be possible for Iraq and us to have a completely normal relationship.
ReplyDelete2. Obama and al-Maliki hope that Iraq will use the U.S. as an example for a democracy and become more stable. I think this is possible because their leader seems like he really believes in democracy. If the leader did not fully believe in it I do not think Iraq would end up as a stable country. I think it will take time to get everyone on board but eventually they will be stable. Also, by teaching them how to use our weapons they will be able to defend their own country. I think this may be possible if we can cooperate and are really focused on making Iraq better. Like Sami said no one comes out with a great army. They become great after training and focusing on it. If we are fully committed to helping Iraq then we need to spend more time with them until they can stand on their own two feet. In summary, I think all that Obama and al-Maliki are trying to do is possible.
3. I agree with Baylee, Molly, Edj and Sami that it is a good idea that we are withdrawing the troops from Iraq. I think both nations were focused on the war too much. Each nation has problems they should focus on instead. By taking the soldiers out of Iraq we can regain focus and so can Iraq. Also by taking out the soldiers Iraq has a chance to fix their mistakes. They have the opportunity to redo their government, and protect themselves.
1) I agree with Baylee, I do not think that the U.S. and Iraq will ever be able to have a completely normal relationship again. Although, as Erica mentions, both Obama and al-Maliki want to establish a relationship I don't think it would ever work. This is because the two nations have gone through so much, and I doubt that anyone will ever forget that.
ReplyDelete2) Obama and al-Maliki hope that Iraq qill be able to protect itself when the American troops leave. They also hope that Iraq qill be a sucessful democratic nation. I agree with Erica in that Iraq is not ready to be completely on its own, but with the help that the U.S. is willing to give them they will eventually be able to take care of themselves, and hopefully be successful in it.
3) I agree with Erica, Lizzie,and Baylee, removing our troops has many safety benefits for the soldiers and the country. I also agree with Erica in that it is helping Iraq become independent. We cannot stay with them forever, or else they will never really be able to learn how to take care of itself. We have done a lot for the country and it is time for Iraq to go off on its own. It is kind of like riding a bike. If you rely on your training wheels for too long, you will eventually be too scared to ever take them off. It is the same with this situation, if the U.S. satys in Iraq for much longer Iraq qill rely on us so much, that they will be to scared to ever let us go and will never be fully on its own. The troops leaving is like taking off the training wheels, the first couple tries Iraq will fall, but close behind the U.S. will be there to give them some tips. Eventually, Iraq will be sucessful and will noy have to depend on the U.S. at all.
1.) I agree with Lizzie, I do not think that Iraq and the United States with have a completely normal relationship once the war is over. So much has happened in these past nine year, which will cause the two countries to struggling with putting the past behind them. Like Taylor said, there will still be grudges held against one another. The amount of casualties and injuries in the war will not be forgotten, and it will be a struggle to overcome this issue for both countries.
ReplyDelete2.) Obama and al-Maliki hope that once the American troops have completely left the country, Iraq will be able to move forward independently as its own nation. There are hopes that Iraq will eventually become a democratic nation. Personally, I think that Iraq will struggle on its own. Iraq is used to having other countries help them form a government, and likeLucy said, without the help Iraq will struggle to accomplish their goals.
3.) I agree with Baylee, and think it is a good thing that America has withdrawn their troops from Iraq. The war has gone on for too long, and too many people were killed as a result of it. With the troops gone, hopefully Iraq can focus on creating a democratic government they can be proud of.
1. I agree with Baylee and I don't think that it is possible for America and Iraq to establish a normal relationship such as one we have with countries we have never been in war with. I think that no matter how hard we try, grudges will still be held. Like Lucy I think that both countries have gone through so much and the past eight years will not be forgotten.
ReplyDelete2. Obama and Al- Malaki think that removing US troops from Iraq will make Iraq more independent and be able to protect themselves. They also believe that without a war, Iraq will be able to focus on establishing a democracy. I do agree with these goals because war can be a big distraction and without these distractions, they will be able to do more productive things done like work on their government. But I do agree with Lucy that this could take a while and will be harder than the countries anticipate.
3. I think that removing troops from Iraq will benefit both America and Iraq. I think that it will take away the distractions of war and it will allow Iraq to focus on their government and America to focus on the war in Afghanistan and be able to take troops away from there too. Like Lucy, both countries will remain safer without any threats from each other and having to put citizens lives on the line when they could be with their families.
1) I agree with Sami and Edj that overtime, a normal relationship can be formed between Iraq and America. Sami provided a good example about Germany and America. We now have a normal relationship although we had issues in the past. In years to come, Iraq and America can have a civil, normal relationship.
ReplyDelete2) Obama and al-Maliki hope that eventually, they can have a good relationship between their respective countries and that Iraq can be a productive, independent country. I think that Iraq needs help to become the country we hope they can be, but they will get there if all goes as planned. With the help from American personnel, they can become a fully functioning and independent country. I do hope that other countries, especially Iran, will not interfere with these plans. If America continues to help and Iraq is willing to stand up and do what they need to do, then they can be a great country soon enough.
3) I think that there is a good side and a bad side to withdrawing our troops from Iraq, like Lizzie said. It may not be the best thing for Iraq, because they are not yet ready to take the reigns and protect their own country. However, after all these years, American troops should not have to be put at risk in Iraq. Their families at home need them and want them back. There is an argument for both sides. I know that it is not the best thing to do politically to remove the troops all of the sudden, but yet it is hard to imagine families going without their loved ones any longer. It is a tough decision, but I am sure that the capable leaders of both countries will make sure that they do what is best.
1) I agree and think that a normal relationship can be formed. Both countries have new leaders than when the war started, and I think that's very important in building positive ties.
ReplyDelete2) President Obama and Al-Maliki say that they want to build a normal relationship and that they want to establish trade and that America wants to help Iraq make its new government. I think it's possible for this vision to become reality because America has good intentions and Iraq's leader doesn't seem bitter about the war, even claiming it a success.
3) I think it's a good thing that we are withdrawing troops from Iraq because as Al-Maliki said, terrorism and al Qaeda are no longer in Iraq. We have no reason for troops to be in the Iraq anymore, seeing as how President Obama says that we will lend our support in rebuilding Iraq's government once troops are withdrawn.
1. I do not think that it is possible for American to have a completely normal relationship with Iraq due to all of the things that have happened in the past 8 years. There are also a lot of grudges that need to be forgotten in order for such a relationship to happen. There is however that off chance that if President Obama and al-Maliki work well enough together that the two countries can become great allies.
ReplyDelete2. The President and al-Maliki hope that Iraq will become an independent nation once America’s military presence is lifted. I do not think that it is possible for Iraq to be an independent nation because the last government that they had was a dictatorship and it will take time for the new democracy to be built.
3. I agree with what Andrew said and I also disagree. I agree by him saying that the troops no longer need to be in Iraq anymore because America can lend a hand in building their government from here. I disagree with him about that fact that there is no longer terrorism in Iraq. There is terrorism almost everywhere and to say that there is None in an entire country is an overstatement in my opinion.
1) I agree with Erica, Tatyana, Edj, and Sami. I think that that over time, a normal relationship can be formed between America and Iraq. Just like other things in life, it takes both sides to let go of their past and trust the other side. It will definitely take time though, because it took so long to get this way, so it will take just as long (if not longer) to undo the past. It will take both sides to forget their past with each other, and it won't be easy. It will take the nations' utmost strength to forgive and forget everyone's grudges. It will take both sides to accomplish this task, otherwise the relationship will continue as is.
ReplyDelete2) Barrack Obama and al-Maliki hope that Iraq will be able to protect itself without the aid of the US once the U.S. military is no longer present in Iraq. Also, they might be thinking that if they remove the troops, both nations will be able to move on and (like Question 1) begin forming a normal relationship. I do not think they will be able to move forward while Iraq is depending on the U.S. and the U.S. is keeping any personnel in Iraq. I think that their visions are possible, but that both nations have to cooperate their share by relying on another - for example, Iraq helps out America on one matter while America helps out Iraq on something else. It cannot keep on going one sided.
3) I think it is a lovely idea that the United States is withdrawing its military presence from Iraq. I believe that so many soldiers have given their lives for not only this country, but Iraq as well and that families deserve their loved ones back. In addition, with no more U.S. troops in Iraq, the Iraqi government can hopefully concentrate on forming a democratic government by themselves to how they see fit. I think there is no harm in removing the troops for the US' standpoint. They will have the chance to decide whether A: they want to continue assisting Iraq and B: whether Iraq needs the help from us anymore. I believe that overall it is a great decision and that maybe it could have been done sooner than this.
1.) I don't think that it is possible to create a normal relationship between the two countries, at least not within the next 100 years. As long as there are people who remember this war, people will think of Iraq as terrorists and enemies. And in Iraq, people will still despise America for coming into their country. Overtime though, people will forget the hostility as they have done with Vietnam and Russia, but the relationship between the countries will never be the same.
ReplyDelete2.)Obama and Al-Maliki believe that one day, Iraq will become just like America. They believe that everyone will be free, equal, and a democracy will be the head of the country. They want to be able to protect themselves from threats both out side and inside the country as Baylee said. I do believe this could happen, but I think it will be very hard. Things over in Iraq are much different than things in America. The government would have to work hard to form a country just like ours. Yet, I do believe they could do it because they see what life is like here and really want it for themselves and their people. Overtime, things will change and Iraq will become more democratic and fair.
3.)I think it is a good idea to be withdrawing from Iraq. As Baylee said, how can Iraq grow while they feel dependent on another country. By having to face issues by themselves, they will learn and grow. Another reason withdrawing is good is because this war is using up loads of money that the country could use in other places. The money spent on war could be used to stimulate the economy by creating projects and jobs. Finally, the war is taking the lives of our citizens. If we withdraw we save lives, especially those of young men and women.
1. I think that it is possible for America to build a normal relationship with Iraq. Given the previous conflict, the U.S. has made a huge effort to build the Iraqi infrastructure back and gain the support of the people. Plus the U.S has provided much security training and supplies to help the Iraqi military.
ReplyDelete2. They hope that Iraq will be able to have a strong and successful government. They hope that the Iraqi people will be able to live safe and happy lives. I am not sure if this could happen because there is still a lot of tension and unrest in the region. Plus there are nations like Iran that could interfere with the government there.
3. I think that it is a good idea to bring U.S. troops home because they have made so many sacrifices. There contribution has helped to bring stability and safety back to the country and that they should return home to the comfort of their families.
1. I believe that, even though our governments have decided on a “normal relationship,” their people may feel resentment towards our soldiers, and vice-versa. Our people might have killed family members of the Iraqis, and the Iraqis killed many of our soldiers. Families, who have felt loss on both sides of the war front, may see only the hate for all those in Iraq, and families in Iraq may hat the Americans for all the pain, and loss that their countries have received.
ReplyDelete2. Obama and al-Maliki hope that once the U.S. military is no longer present in Iraq, there will be a “comprehensive partnership” between the two countries. The U.S. goal for Iraq, “is a sovereign Iraq that can protect its borders, protect its airspace, protect its people," says President Obama. I believe that this vision for Iraq is possible, but not right away. If Iraq is able to pull together its falling-apart country, I do think that Iraq will be able to protect its people.
3. I think it is a good and a bad thing if we pull our troops out of Iraq. I think it would be a good thing because many of our families wouldn’t be separated anymore, and people wouldn’t have to raise children without their mother or father being there. I think it’s a bad thing as well. I think it’s a bad idea because perhaps Iraq may be completely razed by the time our last soldier has left. And with a government run by terrorists, who control our oil supply, we would fall to the hands of people who would destroy landmarks, and kill innocent men, women, and children, just to show they have power.
1:I do not believe we can have "normal relations" with Iraq because they never wanted us there in the first place and since then violence has been building up. I also think throughout time we might have good relations, but not anytime soon.
ReplyDelete2:They hope that by removing our troops Iraq will be able to protect and help themselves in scenarios similar to this. I beleive these visions are possible, but i dont think we should remove all the troops at once, we need to do it gradually to help them adapt to what will change.
3: I do belive it is a good thing because it is puting our troops in unnecisary danger and iraq needs to be able to protect themselves.
1) I dont believe that we can or could have had normal relation with Iraq. We could have with the ones that did want us to come over in the first place. But we defiantly could not have had relations with the ones that had supported the terriost attacks in the first part. This causes them not to like and make relations with them.
ReplyDelete2) By removing the troops from Iraq that the Iranians will be able to sort of control themselves and not to do any of the attacks on anyone anymore. I think that it was smart to remove the troops at different times so that they will not attacks us at once.
3) I think that this was a good idea to remove the troops.
1. I agree wiht ben and kyle in saying that we could never have relations wiht iraq because they do not want us there.
ReplyDelete2. They hope that if we leave Iraq then iraq will be able to become indipendent and not need our military to support them.
3.I think that it was a great idea to remove out troops, because now we will not be killing our own men and women to try and protect another country
1. I agree with Marcus that it is possible for Iraq to still form relations with the US. During the revolutionary war, the United States and Great Britain were antagonists, but now we are in an alliance with them and we have fought beside as friends in World War I and World War II.
ReplyDelete2. Both leaders hope that the two countries will be able to form military ties, and they hope that Iraq will once again rebuild its military force. They also hope that Iraq will be able to survive on its own and will not need support from other countries again.
3. I agree with Ben that it was a good idea to remove the troops. If American troops had still remained in Iraq then the citizens of Iraq would continue to be angry that there are foreign troops in their land. I also think it is a good idea because it would be good to have Iraq be able to support itself without America's help.
1.In my opinion, even though our countries may see ourselves having normal relations, but really we can't have friendly relations with them. The tension between the nations is too high with all the fighting. Some of the people there are mad at the soldiers killing people they loved, and the soldiers feel the same way towards the Iraqi's.
ReplyDelete2. Obama believes that Iraq can protect itself without our military support if we leave Iraq. I agree with his beliefs because we have set up a proper government for them that they can. They have all the materials they need to become independent.
3.I agree with most people when saying that its a good idea to remove our troops from Iraq. This way there will not be killing and hatred towards the nations and we can let the country run itself, without wasting our resources.
1. If there is going to be a "normal relationship" between Iraq and America, it will have to come with time. Eight whole years of conflict is not just water under the bridge. I am assuming that a "normal relationship" between countries is a good report, and that can't happen with the history between America and Iraq. And if it does happen, it would not be built on a solid foundation.
ReplyDelete2. They believe that once America is gone, Iraq will be able to function and protect themselves without the U.S.'s help. As with the first question, this will require a lot of time. I think it is definitely possible for Iraq to fend for itself, although it has been holding America's hand for eight years. It is also still developing democracy, so if it is going to work out, it will be a very rocky start.
3. Well when you look at it in the short term, it is a bad thing, because it involves a lot of risk on both countries' parts. But in the long run, I think it is the best thing for Iraq. They need to learn how to fend for themselves, and sometimes you have to get thrown in the deep end. I think it was the right choice, although it may not seem like it for some years to come.
1. I agree with Hannah, I think the US and Iraq can rebuild a "normal relationship". I do think though that it will take a lot of effect and will come over time. After all that has happened between the countries it won't be easy to create full peace and a normal relationship. Both countries will have to prove that they want peace and a normal relationship with the other country. I liked how Sami related it to the Americanm and Germany relationship, I think that is a great example to prove this thought.
ReplyDelete2.Obama and al-Maliki hope that Iraq will have the ability to survive on it's own. The article states, "Our goal is simply to make sure Iraq succeeds, because we think a successful, democratic Iraq can be a model for the entire region," Obama said" This is a great quote because it shows exactly what Obama wants for Iraq once the troops are taken out of there. They also want Iraq to be able to defend themselves if neighboring countries were to attack(such as Iran). I 100% that it is possible for this to happen. It may not happeen right away, it may take some time but if Iraq it willing to prove that they are a stronger country now and we are willing to help them then yes I think it is very possible that what they want will be possible.
3. This question can be very contriversal in many ways. There are good sides and bad sides to the US troops being taken out of Iraq. But my opinion is that is it a good thing they are bringing the troops home. For one reason they have been there for such a long time I know they will be greatful for coming home. Secondly, Iraq needs to be able to stand for themselves and show the strength they have gained and they will now be able to do that with our troops not there anymore to help protect them.
1. I agree with everyone who says no. I do not believe that the U.S. and Iraq can rebuild a normal relationship. We have been at war with Iraq for 8 years, causing a lot of hatred and discrimination between the two countries. A lot of people died in those 8 years, people from both sides. I believe the countries can build a civil relationship that involves trading and communication. They will not build a relationship that will end with friendship though. Iraq doesn't want the U.S. in their country and they never will.
ReplyDelete2. Obama and al-Maliki hope that Iraq can become independent once the troops leave. Obama hopes that Iraq can become a successful, democratic country. He hopes that Iraq can become a model for the rest of the region. They also want Iraq to be able to defend them self against other countries. I would like to think that these hopes are possible after 8 years in Iraq. Hopefully Iraq will realize what the best decision for their country is, and stick to it.
3. I believe there are pros and cons to withdrawing from Iraq. The pro is that we get our soldiers back, and Iraq is forced to be independent. Another pro is that hopefully we can become civil with Iraq. A con is the lack of protection we have now. We cannot stop Iraq from coming into our country once our troops leave. Iraq could also think that once we leave, it is a chance to attack us. Hopefully, the pros will outweigh the cons. I personally believe it was the right decision to remove our troops.
1. i do not think that the USA can ever buid a normal relationship with iraq. We have been at war with them for eight years, and i dont think that we can ever be buddy-buddy with them. Partners, sure, but not friends.
ReplyDelete2. Obama and al-maliki want iraq to become an independent, successful, and democratic. i think that this is very possible if the iraqis decide to go with it. they can be the role model for the whole middle east.
3. I think that the troops leaving is a good thing. Families will get their husbands back, iraq is on the next step to freedom, and we can possible do trade with iraq. Overall, the good parts about the troops leaving outweigh any bad parts that there might be.
1) I think it is possible for the U.S. to build a normal relationship with Iraq. Even though much damage was done, and many people died, the two countries can have a normal relationship. Of coarse it is going to take a lots and lots of time. Like Marcus and Kyle said, we've beed in two huge Wars with Great Britain, and now we are allies and friends with them.
ReplyDelete2)Obama and Al-Maliki hope that Iraq can take care of itself and like Sean said become independent, successful, and democratic without the help of the U.S. I think this is possible because when the U.S. leaves, Iraq will learn how to be all those things through mistakes, and experiences they will face, and eventually they will learn to do things on their own and will not need the U.S's help at all.
3)I think that it is a very good thing that the U.S, is withdrawing its troops from Iraq because of two reasons. One, this will give Iraq the opportunity to learn to function on their own, and become independent, and two, lots of families will be reunited, which is a very good thing.